The Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) industry in the United States has officially entered its regulated era. What began as a frictionless checkout button has become a $75+ billion credit market that now answers to the same federal agency that oversees Visa, Mastercard, and American express.

On May 22, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) issued its landmark interpretive rule declaring that most digital BNPL products are functionally credit cards under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z). The rule took effect July 30, and completely rewrote the compliance landscape overnight.

This guide is the most current, detailed, and actionable breakdown available anywhere online as of July. Every requirement, deadline, penalty, state variation, and consumer right is documented here with direct government sources.

1. The Sungle Most Important Rule Change in BNPL History

CFPB Interpretive Rule (Effective July 30)
Official Federal Register publication: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/05/31/2024-11539/consumer-financial-protection-bureau-interpretive-rule-on-buy-now-pay-later

Key takeaway: Any BNPL lender offering four or fewer interest-free installments (the “pay-in-4” model used by 92% of the market) is now legally a credit card issuer under Regulation Z.

This triggers the exact same consumer protections that have applied to traditional credit cards since 1968.

Mandatory Consumer Protections Now in Effect

Source: CFPB Official Summary – https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/final-rules/buy-now-pay-later-interpretive-rule/

2. State Level Licensing Requirements

While the CFPB rule is federal, many states now require BNPL companies to hold state lending licenses  even for interest-free products.

States That Currently Require BNPL Licensing (as of July)

1. California:  DFPI Financing Law License (required since 2021, aggressively enforced)
   https://dfpi.ca.gov/regulated-industries/debt-collection-program/debt-collection-licensing/
2. New York:  Requires licensing if charging any fee (including late fees)
   NY DFS guidance
3. Utah:  First state to create specific BNPL registration
   Utah HB 243
4. Connecticut:  Requires registration for third-party BNPL providers
5. Colorado:  New law requires licensing for any deferred payment plan >90 days

Companies operating without required state licenses face cease-and-desist orders and per-day fines up to $100,000 (California DFPI precedent set against Sezzle in 2023).

3. What Actually Changed for Consumers on July 30

Real world impact examples from CFPB enforcement actions and consumer complaints database:

Before the rule

•  You returned a $400 dress bought with Afterpay
•  Afterpay kept all four payments
•  You had to fight merchant directly
•  41% success rate (CFPB study)

After the rule

•  You return the dress
•  Merchant issues refund
•  BNPL provider MUST credit your account within 7 days
•  Failure = Regulation Z violation
•  CFPB can fine the lender directly

Same applies to non-delivery, defective products, unauthorized charges, etc.

4. The Three BNPL Business Models and How Regulation Hits Each Differently

Model 1:  Classic Pay-in-4 (Afterpay, Klarna, Zip, Sezzle)

•  Now fully regulated as credit cards
•  Must provide refunds, dispute rights, statements
•  Can still soft-pull credit (no hard inquiry allowed)

Model 2:  Longer-term installment loans (Affirm, Klarna 6–36 months)

•  Already regulated as closed-end credit since 2021
•  Must do ability-to-repay (ATR) assessment
•  Hard inquiries permitted
•  Interest up to 36% APR allowed

Model 3:  Virtual cards / single-use cards (Klarna “Pay in 30”, Affirm virtual card at checkout)

•  Explicitly included in CFPB May rule
•  Must comply with open-end credit rules (same as Apple Card)

5. Late Fees: The Next Regulatory Battleground

CFPB has explicitly stated it is examining BNPL late fees under the “reasonable and proportional” standard applied to credit cards.

Current late fee landscape:

• Afterpay: $8 cap (self-imposed after CFPB pressure)
• Klarna: Up to $7 (US), $0 in some states
• Zip: Up to $10
• Affirm: $0 late fees (competitive advantage)
• Sezzle: Up to $10 (being challenged in California class action)

CFPB Director Rohit Chopra public statement:
We are actively reviewing whether current BNPL late fee structures violate the reasonableness requirement.

6. Consumer Complaint Data: The Numbers Behind the Regulation

CFPB Consumer Complaint Database (filtered for BNPL)

• Total BNPL complaints: 18,400+
• Top issue (42%): Can’t get refund for returned item
• Second issue (29%): Unexpected late fees after autopay failure
• Third issue (18%): Multiple loans leading to overdraft chains

Source: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/consumer-complaints/

7. How To Use BNPL Safely Under the New Rules

Actionable checklist every consumer should follow:

1.  Always screenshot the periodic statement (now required) — it is your legal evidence.
2.  If a refund is not credited within 10 days of merchant refund, file a dispute in writing (email counts).
3.  You now have 60 days to dispute billing errors (previously ~10 days with most providers).
4.  Never use more than one BNPL at once on the same paycheck  overdraft risk remains your responsibility.
5.  Check your state’s licensing database before using a lesser-known provider.

8. Future Regulatory Timeline (Confirmed & Expected)

Q3 – CFPB expected to propose formal BNPL rulemaking (beyond interpretive rule)
Possible ability-to-repay requirement for pay-in-4 (industry fighting hard against this)
FTC Section 5 enforcement against dark patterns in BNPL rules usa checkout flow
Potential inclusion of BNPL in credit reports (Affirm already reports positive-only others may follow)

READ MORE:  Tax Problems in the U.S.: Complete Guide to Federal & State Tax Issues, Solutions, and Prevention